The Best Little Whorehouse in Texas 1982
A robust musical song and dance tour de force in celebration of the old time, mostly obsolete western brothel, this movie has one of the most entertaining opening 20 minutes of any of hooker movie: pure musical/sexual hilarity. It just goes to show that with a little money, sex, cooperation from the sheriff, and proper supervision, folks can have some "good, clean fun." It's actually a true story of a long term brothel in a country farm house in Texas which made big news in the early 1970's when it was shut down, and an article appeared in Playboy telling the story. You can't beat Dolly Partin as the madam, Mona, and Burt Reynolds as the sheriff, Ed Earl. Though the songs are mostly forgettable and the dialogue is "high school sophomoric" in places, there are moments when either the pure enthusiasm or the personal drama really touch the heart. When you see prostitutes dancing with johns like it was Agnes de Mille choreography and either Oklahoma or the Music Man, it sort of levels the playing field concerning what's "right and wrong."
An unexpectedly poignant scene finds Mona and sheriff Ed Earl having a campfire rendezvous on a lonesome Texas hillside, drinking a six-pack and looking at the stars. Mona and Ed Earl have been lovers for years, and they are talking about life, love, religion, sex, morality, legality, and sin. It's a conversation worth hearing as they snuggled in the firelight. More than a conversation, it's a social/political treatise on the absurdity of the moral self-righteousness of our laws regarding consensual sex between adults.
The story spins on as a Houston TV personality starts a crusade to close Mona and her girls down. The brothel, called the "Chicken Ranch" got it's name from the 1930's depression era when clients had no money and paid in live chickens. It had been a respite for both World War I soldiers, and then their sons during WW II. And, the University of Texas or Texas Aggies senior football players, whichever won the yearly game, always got a visit to the Ranch, presumably paid by wealthy alumni. Mona had built enormous goodwill over the years with her courtesy, her clean and healthy business, and her charitable contributions.
As the drama weaves its tale to the final conclusion, real lives, and wounded hearts are on the line. By this point, sentimental sap that I am, tears are running down my face, and I'm blubbering in piles of kleenex. Mona sings, "And I Will Always Love You" to Ed Earl and I'm a puddle in my chair. Dolly Partin had written the song several years earlier, and though it wasn't in the Broadway version, it was added to the movie (clearly the movie's best song.) Ten years later Whitney Houston sang it in the movie, Bodyguard, and it became one of the top selling single songs of all time.
So this romanticized story, which stays pretty close to the actual events in Texas sort of put an exclamation point for me on what I have been feeling for the last six months. As the year 2009 began, I was the same old Richard I had always been, struggling for personal or romantic fulfillment in any number of frustrating and unproductive ways. The possibility of seeing a prostitute or escort or hooker or whatever you want to call her had never occurred to me. In fact, I probably disapproved of such practice, though I never gave much thought to whether I did or didn't.
My decision to partake of "love for sale" was not a well considered decision. It was more like something kicked me in the butt and said, "Get out and live a life, or you are going to die alone and lonely." Within a couple of hours of hearing that voice, I was withdrawing hundreds of dollars from an ATM machine. Six months later, I found Pearl. Was there a connection? Never had I thought that seeing an escort or two or three was the key to the door that would open me up to living a life with real women rather than sitting at home dying alone with my fantasies. As a good friend of mine always says, "You've got to get out and meet and greet the people!"
This experience has also changed my attitude toward the world's oldest profession. From this point on, I will always make an effort to promote the legalization of prostitution in the U.S. (as this movie does,) and to defend the legal and civil rights of prostitutes. And, it’s changed my attitude toward relationships in general. Go ahead, make mistakes, talk about it, forgive and embrace, respect everyone, and be tolerant of however hapless humans choose to find love.
Risky Business 1983
What can you say? The best feel good hooker movie ever? Tom Cruise dances in his jockey shorts in one of the classic comic scenes of all time (and 26 years later it is still copied as a TV commercial during the NCAA basketball tourney), and the movie just keeps getting better after that scene. A business night of fun in the Chicago suburbs. If ever there were a positive portrayal of the profession, this was it. Then to cap it off, Rebecca de Mornay makes the hottest of hot love on the Chicago elevated train.
Pretty Woman 1990
Really, this is a love story, whose female character happens to be a prostitute. It's more of a rich guy/poor pretty girl story. And, it has a fine twist on the Pygmalion plot, where, rather than try to reform or educate Julia Roberts, the rich guy (Richard Gere) delights in her lack of sophistication, and makes everyone respect her in spite of it. Of course, they fall in love, and it's happiness and money ever after. Again, it hints but barely that Gere is reaping enormous sexual benefits in this arrangement. He gets love, and one hell of a hot woman at the same time.
Mighty Aphrodite 1995
I must be a sucker for a movie, because this one's really stupid, but I liked it anyway. New York plot scenes alternate with a comic Greek chorus which offer farce-like narration from the ruins of some old Greek theater. It's another Woody Allen film (how many has he made? a thousand by now?) and he acts in it. How does such a nerd always get the pretty girls? It proves there's hope for any guy with imagination. The story is that Allen's character, Lenny, and his wife, Amanda, adopt a baby. Lenny finds out that the baby's birth mother is a prostitute/porn star, Linda Ash played by Mira Sorvino, who at 5'10" has legs that make fools of wise men and we see plenty of them. Linda's hooker character is pretty dumb, much in contrast to the usual savvy heroine of hooker movies. But, she has a big heart, moral character, and a refreshingly blunt, unashamed enthusiasm about sex which comes out in constant hilarious one-liners. The plot never has the interpersonal punch that it promises, particularly in reconciling birth mother and child, but it ends with everybody happy, and the Greek chorus singing "When You're Smiling, the Whole World Smiles With You." What's not to like?
Dangerous Beauty 1998
True story of Veronica Franco,
a courtesan in Venice in the late 1500's. It portrays prostitution as a product of social structure, it contrasts "love for sale" vs. "true love," and it covers all sides of the issue: boring wives vs. love wise courtesans, men who want both, social and religious hypocrisy, courtesans who influence history, and hookers with hearts of gold. Every character is an idealized, romanticized model. Though, in stark realism it describes the severe syphilis epidemic that plagued Venice during this period. It seems that the Catholic church blamed the syphilis epidemic on prostitution and started executing them as heretics. Sounds like things have not changed much today since escorts are still blamed for STD's though the statistics show that they are a minor source of them. The movie is well worth seeing.
Moulin Rouge 2001
This is one of the silliest movies I've seen in a long time, a slapstick musical that I had difficulty watching all the way through, except for the fact that I have this thing for Nicole Kidman, whom my sister in Nashville is always seeing at the neighborhood pizza parlor with her hubby Keith Urban. (beside the point I know) This is actually the same story as the 1936 movie, Camille, with Greta Garbo, just turned into a farce musical with Elton John songs. But, the classic hooker movie themes are still present, and probably my favorite scene is when Kidman, the Courtesan, is having an encounter with her young suitor on top of a decorative elephant shaped structure. They sing, banter, and dance while debating the issue of "true love" vs. "love for sale." It's a great scene, but to watch the rest of the movie, I'd suggest having a bottle of booze handy. Then it might be fun. I don’t drink, so it was not that much fun.
Memoirs of a Geisha 2005
A curious movie, with spectacular
photography and sets. A nine year old Japanese girl is sold by her family to a Geisha house. The girl, Sayuri is physically abused and mistreated in the house, but eventually is rescued by a kind and respected Geisha mentor who trains her in the Geisha talents of art, music, literature, and conversation. When Sayuri comes of age, her virginity is auctioned at her debut, a public performance attended by wealthy invited guests. The Geisha seems to have been much more of a social and entertainment companion first, besides being the obligatory sexual partner. It was of course, primarily a business venture, but historically run by women for women, however tough the women were on each other. The ultimate goal was to find one wealthy man who would become the Geisha's sole patron. World War II changes everything, and a tangled love story mixes with business.
Others of this period:
Sharkey's Machine 1981
Night Shift 1982
Trading Places 1983
The Courtesans of Bombay 1983 (India) Netflix
Hollywood Chainsaw Hookers 1987 use your imagination, mercifully this one is unavailable for rent
Leaving Las Vegas 1995, real downer, more about alcoholism
Devdas 2002 (India)
The Whore's Son (Hurensohn) 2004, Austria, a teenage son wonders why his mother keeps going out at night, then discovers she is a prostitute.
Monster 2003, sad, but true story, very difficult to watch
Sakuran 2006 (Japan)